 | 24 North Hotel Key West Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 145 | Key West |
| Alexander Palms Court Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 12 | Key West |
| Almond Tree Inn Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 22 | Key West |
 | Banana Bay Resort Key West Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 48 | Key West |
 | BAYSIDE INN & SUITES KEY WEST Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 2.0 star rating | 64 | Key West |
 | Best Western Key Ambassador Resort Inn Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 100 | Key West |
 | Best Western Plus Hibiscus Motel Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 61 | Key West |
 | Casa Marina A Waldorf Astoria Resort Florida Keys - FL | 5.0 star rating | 311 | Key West |
| Chelsea House Pool and Gardens Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Key West |
 | Coconut Mallory Resort Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 34 | Key West |
| Courtyard Key West Waterfront Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 68 | Key West |
 | Doubletree Grand Key Resort Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 216 | Key West |
 | Fairfield Inn and Suites - Keys Collection Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 133 | Key West |
 | Fairfield Inn & Suites Key West Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 106 | Key West |
 | Heron House Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 23 | Key West |
| Hilton Garden Inn Key West - Keys Collection Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 141 | Key West |
 | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 118 | Key West |
| Key Lime Inn Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 37 | Key West |
 | Key West Marriott Beachside Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 215 | Key West |
 | La Concha Hotel & Spa Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 160 | Key West |
 | Margaritaville Key West Resort & Marina Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 178 | Key West |
 | Ocean Key Resort & Spa Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 100 | Key West |
| Paradise Inn Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 18 | Key West |
| Parrot Key Resort Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Key West |
| Pier House Resort & Caribbean Spa Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 142 | Key West |
 | Reflections at Ocean Key House Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Key West |
 | Sheraton Suites Key West Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 183 | Key West |
 | Silver Palms Inn Key West Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 50 | Key West |
| Southernmost House Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Key West |
| Southernmost On The Beach Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 261 | Key West |
 | Sunset Key West Guest Cottages Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 40 | Key West |
| The Gates Hotel Key West Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 245 | Key West |
| The Grand Guesthouse Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Key West |
 | The Inn at Key West Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 105 | Key West |
 | The Reach A Waldorf Astoria Resort Florida Keys - FL | 4.0 star rating | 150 | Key West |
 | Travelodge Suites Key West Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 64 | Key West |
 | Weatherstation Inn Hotel Florida Keys - FL | 3.0 star rating | 8 | Key West |