 | America's Best Value Inn Ocean Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 35 | Beach Area |
 | Beacher's Lodge Oceanfront Suites Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 86 | Beach Area |
 | Best Western Bayfront Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 59 | City Area |
 | Best Western Historical Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 39 | City Area |
 | Best Western I-95 & SR16 Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 108 | City Area |
 | Best Western Seaside Inn-St. Augustine Beach Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 50 | Beach Area |
 | Best Western Spanish Quarters Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 40 | City Area |
| Bluegreen Vacations Grande Villas at World Golf Vi Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 33 | City Area |
 | Casa Monica Resort & Spa St Augustine Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 138 | City Area |
 | Castillo Real, an Ascend Collection hotel Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 60 | Beach Area |
| Castle Garden Bed & Breakfast Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 7 | City Area |
 | Comfort Inn & Suites Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 54 | Beach Area |
 | Comfort Suites Downtown St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 51 | City Area |
 | Courtyard By Marriott St Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 95 | City Area |
 | Courtyard St. Augustine Beach Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Beach Area |
 | Days Inn St Augustine/Historic Downtown Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 119 | City Area |
 | Days Inn St. Augustine West Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 120 | City Area |
| Doubletree by Hilton St. Augustine Historic Distri Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 97 | City Area |
 | Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott St.Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 82 | City Area |
 | Hampton Inn St. Augustine Beach Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 100 | Beach Area |
 | Hampton Inn St. Augustine-Historic District Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 53 | City Area |
 | Hampton Inn St. Augustine - I-95 Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 67 | City Area |
 | Hampton Inn & Suites St. Augustine-Vilano Beac Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 94 | Beach Area |
 | Hibiscus Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Beach Area |
 | Hilton Garden Inn St. Augustine Beach Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 83 | Beach Area |
 | Hilton St. Augustine Historic Bayfront Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 72 | City Area |
| Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Saint Augustine St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | City Area |
| Holiday Inn Hotel & Suites St. Augustine St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 120 | Beach Area |
 | Holiday Isle Oceanfront Resort St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 150 | Beach Area |
 | Howard Johnson Inn Historic Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 77 | City Area |
 | Howard Johnson St. Augustine/ I-95 Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 141 | City Area |
 | Inn at Camachee Harbor Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 19 | Beach Area |
 | Knights Inn St Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 31 | City Area |
 | La Quinta Inn and Suites St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 60 | City Area |
| Peace and Plenty Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 8 | City Area |
 | Penny Farthing Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 9 | City Area |
 | Quality Inn St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 48 | City Area |
 | Quality Inn & Suites Saint Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 70 | Beach Area |
| Renaissance St. Augustine Resort World Golf Villag St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | City Area |
 | Sawgrass Marriott Golf Resort & Spa St Augustine Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 510 | Sawgrass |
 | Sleep Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 50 | Beach Area |
 | St. Augustine Hotel & Suites At World Golf Village St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 162 | City Area |
| St. Augustine Island Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 38 | Beach Area |
| St Francis Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 17 | City Area |
 | Super 8 Motel - St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 50 | Beach Area |
 | Super 8 Motel St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 62 | City Area |
 | The Beach Club at St. Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Beach Area |
 | The Kenwood Inn Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 13 | City Area |
 | The Ponce St Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 84 | City Area |
 | Travelodge Suites St Augustine Hotel St Augustine Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 29 | City Area |