 | Anchor Inn & Cottages Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 12 | Sanibel Island |
 | Caribe Beach Resort Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
 | Casa Ybel Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 114 | Sanibel Island |
 | Gulf Breeze Cottages Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 11 | Sanibel Island |
| Hilton Grand Vacations Sanibel Cottages Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 28 | Sanibel Island |
| Hilton Grand Vacations Tortuga Beach Club Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
 | Holiday Inn Sanibel Island Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 98 | Sanibel Island |
 | Lighthouse Resort and Club Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
 | Pelicans Roost Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 20 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Arms West Condominium Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 30 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Beach Club Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 31 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Beach Club II Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Harbour by Resort Harbour Properties Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 55 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Harbour Marriott Resort & Spa Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 190 | Sanibel Island |
| Sanibel Inn Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 93 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sanibel Moorings Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 122 | Sanibel Island |
| Seaside Inn Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 32 | Sanibel Island |
 | Shalimar Cottages and Motel Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 33 | Sanibel Island |
| Song of the Sea Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 30 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sundial Beach Resort & Spa Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | 400 | Sanibel Island |
 | Sunset Beach Inn Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 46 | Sanibel Island |
 | Surfrider Beach Club Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
| Tortuga Beach Club Resort Fort Myers Area - FL | 4.0 star rating | | Sanibel Island |
 | Tropical Winds Motel & Cottages Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 2.0 star rating | 10 | Sanibel Island |
 | West Wind Inn Hotel Fort Myers Area - FL | 3.0 star rating | 102 | Sanibel Island |