 | Best Western Arcata Inn Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 62 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Best Western Country Inn Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 66 | Fortuna |
 | Best Western Plus Bayshore Inn Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 129 | Old Town |
 | Best Western Plus Humboldt Bay Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 111 | Old Town |
 | Clarion Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 66 | Old Town |
| Comfort Inn Arcata-Humboldt Area Hotel Eureka - CA | Without Official Category | | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Comfort Inn Humboldt Bay Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 48 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Comfort Inn & Suites Redwood Country Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 51 | Fortuna |
 | Days Inn Eureka CA Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 37 | Old Town |
 | Days Inn & Suites Arcata CA Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 57 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Econo Lodge Hotel Eureka - CA | 1 Star And A Half | 41 | Old Town |
 | Hampton Inn & Suites Arcata Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 82 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
| Holiday Inn Express and Suites Eureka Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | | Eureka Arcata Airport |
| Holiday Inn Express Arcata/Eureka Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 84 | Old Town |
 | Howard Johnson Express Arcata Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 49 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
| MOTEL 6 EUREKA Hotel Eureka - CA | 2.0 star rating | 98 | Old Town |
 | Quality Inn Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 64 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Quality Inn Hotel Eureka - CA | 2.0 star rating | 60 | Old Town |
| Red Lion Eureka Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 175 | Old Town |
 | Red Roof Inn Arcata Hotel Eureka - CA | 2.0 star rating | | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Rodeway Inn Humboldt Bay - Redwood Area Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 27 | Old Town |
 | Super 8 Eureka Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 50 | Old Town |
 | Super 8 Motel - Arcata Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 60 | Eureka Arcata Airport |
 | Super 8 Motel - Fortuna Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 46 | Old Town |
 | The Redwood Fortuna Riverwalk Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | 46 | Old Town |
| Town House Motel Hotel Eureka - CA | 3.0 star rating | | Old Town |
 | Travelodge Eureka Hotel Eureka - CA | 2.0 star rating | 44 | Old Town |